Current:Home > StocksSome Utilities Want a Surcharge to Let the Sunshine In -Thrive Money Mindset
Some Utilities Want a Surcharge to Let the Sunshine In
View
Date:2025-04-27 21:12:22
As more Americans go solar—and save money on their monthly utility bills—electricity providers are doubling down on ways to protect their revenue.
One of the utilities’ most widespread strategies is to impose extra charges on customers who are generating their own energy, and they have had varying degrees of success. At least 11 utilities in nine states have attempted this tactic; five have succeeded.
Power providers say these new rates are needed to ensure their customers using solar and other forms of so-called “distributed generation” continue to pay for the basic costs associated with maintaining the grid.
Clean energy advocates fiercely object, calling these efforts “attacks on solar.” They argue that the utilities don’t adequately account for solar users’ benefits to the grid: less electricity is lost during transportation across power lines; less money spent by utilities on infrastructure for transmission and distribution; credits the utilities can potentially use to reach renewable energy goals or tax credits.
Brad Klein, senior attorney at the Environmental Law and Policy Center, closely tracks these rate cases and has intervened in a few. “In all the [rate] cases I’ve seen so far … utilities never accounted for solar benefits. You end up with a skewed and lopsided analysis that’s insufficient for ratemaking,” he said.
The new charges have ranged from an extra $5 per month for the average Arizona Public Service customer to at least $27 per month for typical Wisconsin customers of Rock Energy Cooperative. These fees largely fall into two categories: fixed charges, which remain stable every month, and demand charges, which vary depending on a customer’s peak electricity usage.
In certain cases, consumers and environmental activists are pushing back by suing the electricity providers or appealing the rates with state regulators. Their latest win came yesterday, when Minnesota’s regulatory commission shot down about $5 worth of monthly fees that Minnesota’s People’s Electric Cooperative put in place for their handful of distributed generation users.
Klein, who participated in the rate appeal, told InsideClimate News, “I’m pleased the Commission so clearly determined that [People’s Electric Cooperative] failed to justify the fee under Minnesota law. It is a clear signal to other utilities that they will need to do a lot more work to be able to justify these kinds of [distributed generation] fees and penalties.”
The cost of installing distributed solar at the residential level has declined steadily over the last five years, according to a new report by the Department of Energy’s Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory. In 2014, the median installed price of U.S. residential solar hit a record low of about $4-per-watt compared to more than $12-per-watt in 1998.
Besides rate changes, other hurdles have also been placed in the path of progress for solar, Klein told InsideClimate News. Some states have rolled back solar tax incentives while others forbid customers from leasing solar panels from third-party providers. This “kitchen-sink approach” is occurring in places where there’s already high solar penetration such as Arizona, as well as in places with few solar users such as Iowa, he added.
InsideClimate News compiled a comprehensive map of utilities’ efforts to tack extra costs onto the monthly electric bills of customers who use rooftop solar panels and other forms of distributed generation.
Correction: A previous version of the story misstated that certain Rock Energy Cooperatives recently received new charges of $90 to their monthly electric bill. This article has been changed to show that these charges added at least $27 per month.
veryGood! (49)
Related
- Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow owns a $3 million Batmobile Tumbler
- Shop the 10 Best-Selling, Top-Rated Amazon Sunglasses for $20 & Under
- Get a $118 J.Crew Shirt for $20, a $128 Swimsuit for $28, a $118 Dress for $28, and More Can't-Miss Deals
- Kate Middleton, Prince William and Their 3 Kids Match in Blue for Easter Church Service
- Newly elected West Virginia lawmaker arrested and accused of making terroristic threats
- Giving up gas-powered cars was a fringe idea. It's now on its way to reality
- This Glimpse of Behati Prinsloo and Adam Levine's New Baby Will Be Loved
- How loss of historical lands makes Native Americans more vulnerable to climate change
- Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow owns a $3 million Batmobile Tumbler
- Baby Foot Is the 1 Thing You Need To Get Your Feet Sandal-Ready for Spring and It’s on Sale Right Now
Ranking
- Could Bill Belichick, Robert Kraft reunite? Maybe in Pro Football Hall of Fame's 2026 class
- Baby Foot Is the 1 Thing You Need To Get Your Feet Sandal-Ready for Spring and It’s on Sale Right Now
- Kristen Stewart’s Birthday Tribute From Fiancée Dylan Meyer Will Make You Believe in True Love
- Aftermath (2020)
- Travis Hunter, the 2
- Hong Kong police arrest 4, accusing them of supporting pro-democracy leaders overseas
- To fight climate change, Ithaca votes to decarbonize its buildings by 2030
- Kim Kardashian Joins American Horror Story Season 12
Recommendation
At site of suspected mass killings, Syrians recall horrors, hope for answers
Here's how to best prepare for winter driving — and what to keep in your car
Thousands protest in Glasgow and around the world for action against climate change
Russia won't say where Wagner boss Yevgeny Prigozhin is, but photos purportedly show his raided home
Apple iOS 18.2: What to know about top features, including Genmoji, AI updates
Taylor Swift and Joe Alwyn Break Up: Relive Their Enchanting 6-Year Love Story
The Arctic has a new record high temperature, according to the U.N.
ISIS leader killed by airstrike in Syria, U.S. Central Command says